Adventures in Nomadic Serendipity
Just because there is a beaten path, that doesn't mean you have to take it...
Movie Review: Into the Wild 
28th-Nov-2008 11:39 pm
face
Into the Wild tells the true story of Christopher McCandless and his tragic quest to challenge himself and rebel against modern society by journeying alone and almost entirely unprepared into the deep Alaskan wilderness in the summer of 1992.

There is a lot I admire about Chris. He went to extremes to break free from the formulas and maps that define modern society, and my heart definitely identifies with his rejection of "stuff" and the pursuit of adventure that was driving him.

But I totally reject his methods. In the end, Chris proved to be a reckless and self-centered dumbass, and though the movie does not show it - his death could have been easily avoided.

Chris graduated from Emory University in 1990, and rather than head off to law school like his family expected, he donated his life savings of $24,000 to charity, and he set off driving west, abandoning his parents and sister, never to speak to them again.

After many adventures along the way he reached Alaska in 1992, where he journeyed into the wilderness with little more than a book about edible plants, a rifle, and a 10lb bag of rice for sustenance.

It was tough living off the land. He did manage to hunt and kill a moose, but he did not know how to preserve the meat and it rotted on him. Before long, he was starving. And when he tried to escape by retracing his steps, he discovered that the shallow river he had waded across early in the season was now a raging and impassible torrent, trapping him.

He lasted a bit over 100 days, living in an old abandoned bus for shelter.

Hunters found his body, his journal, and his cameras full of undeveloped film just two weeks later. His final journal entry: "I HAVE HAD A HAPPY LIFE AND THANK THE LORD. GOODBYE AND MAY GOD BLESS ALL!"

The movie (and the book it was based on) surmised that Chris would have made it had he not accidentally eaten poisonous berries. But no evidence of fatally poisonous berries were ever found in the area, and the more likely scenario is that Chris simply starved to death - expending more calories to find food than he got from eating it. When he was found, his body weighed less than 70lbs.

The movie makes no mention of this - but when I went to read more about Chris and the controversy around his death, I was shocked to discover that there was a hand-operated tram over the river less than a quarter mile from where Chris had found himself trapped and unable to cross. If he had only had a detailed map, he would have been able to walk out to safety.

Just a tiny bit of preparation would have saved him.

*sigh*

The movie dramatizing Chris's life is really good though. It stars Emile Hirsch, and he does an amazing job portraying Chris and the changes he undergoes. The movie was a labor of love for director Sean Penn, who also wrote the screenplay. The location shooting is fabulous, and the beauty and magic of the wilderness is thoroughly captured.

I just wish the movie hadn't tried so hard to make Chris into a heroic figure, when in truth he was more tragic than not. That side of his story was left mostly untold.

Still... A very beautiful, and thought provoking movie. I highly recommend it.

Rating: 4 stars

Note: I am curious to check out a new non-Hollywood documentary about the Christopher McCandless story called The Call of the Wild. To make the movie, the filmmaker physically retraces Chris's journey from a more objective and less hero-worshipping angle. The "Debunking" page on the documentaries website is where I learned a lot about just how misleading the Hollywood drama version had been.
Comments 
29th-Nov-2008 09:14 am (UTC)
Ouch! I'm finding myself going "no-no-no, how could he *do* that?" just reading your description... going into a wilderness is not a good idea for the unprepared and/or clueless. (winces again) Poor guy.
29th-Nov-2008 10:55 am (UTC)
and the soundtrack is great
29th-Nov-2008 04:16 pm (UTC)
Pretty much his story was why I stop subscribing to Outside(?) many years
ago (it was while I was in the Coast Guard so the next line will make some
sense).

They tried to make a hero out of this guy when all he was, was unprepared and well
forgive me for saying this, stupid.
29th-Nov-2008 05:41 pm (UTC)
There is a part of Chris, his spirit, and his story that is heroic. But the author fell so much in love with that part of Chris that he became unable and / or unwilling to see his massive flaws as well.

That the author went to such great lengths to try and concoct an explanation for how Chris may have accidentally died from poisoning in the end actually takes away from his story.

I am curious to check out this documentary about Chris that retraces his journey from a more objective and less hero-worshipping angle. The "Debunking" page linked above is where I learned a lot about just how misleading the movie had been.
29th-Nov-2008 04:49 pm (UTC)
The book is really good too. It is different from the movie, written from the perspective of a detective following Chris' tracks as he interviews the people Chris met and changed along the way (or something like that). Lots of interesting detail not covered on film.
29th-Nov-2008 05:42 pm (UTC)
I want to check out this documentary about Chris that retraces his journey from a more objective and less hero-worshipping angle.

The filmmaker actually retraces Chris's steps all around the country, including (finally) a journey to the real bus that Chris lived in.

The "Debunking" page linked above is where I learned a lot about just how misleading the movie had been.
30th-Nov-2008 06:35 pm (UTC)
He was immature, and I think part of this was the belief that nothing truly devastating can happen to him. His lack of preparation reflected this. But his preparation could have been much worse. What really disappointed me was how easily he gave up when he couldn't find a way out. He just went back to the bus and died. He expected to do something that risky and difficult without some innovative thinking once he finds himself in a bind?

Also, I think he believed in this common American romantic myth of the lone frontiersman. Despite all the people he met along the way who wanted to help and support him, he was determined to ultimately strike out on his own.

The inspiring thing about his story is his refusal to be complacent and just play along with the default standard American path to happiness. He was willing to take the risks and discomfort necessary to find his own way. This is something we both understand and can appreciate I think. :)
3rd-Dec-2008 10:03 am (UTC)
The inspiring thing about his story is his refusal to be complacent and just play along with the default standard American path to happiness. He was willing to take the risks and discomfort necessary to find his own way. This is something we both understand and can appreciate I think. :)

Indeed.
3rd-Dec-2008 06:01 pm (UTC)
I read the Outside Magazine article by Jon Krakauer YEARS ago... actually, I clearly remember reading it my Sophmore year at Wash U. :-) And I just saw the movie too. And I guess, if you saw the movie without any prior knowledge of Chris McCandless, it could be aggravating.

Spoilers ahead...

I found the movie to be quite good. I think the movie portrayed him correctly as a tragic hero. I think the real reason he was trying to get away from it all was his attempt to escape from a somewhat broken home. He did plenty of dumb things and could have died much earlier. Car camping in a wash with a thunderstorm nearby? Burning up his money, only to have to make more later to fund other adventures? Rafting the Grand Canyon without a helmet? And if you did want to get out of the wilderness, why wouldn't you travel upstream to supposedly find the headwaters and maybe a passable river crossing? Also, an interesting side story was his ability to significantly touch people along his path.

Lastly, I wouldn't call him completely "unprepared." He prepared quite a bit for his time before heading in to the Alaska wilderness, and fared far better than most folks could. Obviously, he made a few dumb mistakes.

I think the story is intriguing mainly because of Chris's desire to shun stuff, live a life of adventure, and travel the road less traveled... I suspect many dream of this, and can identify with his desires. Apparently, Jon Krakauer felt the same and turned it into a bestseller!

I thought the end had a great message: "Happiness is only real when shared." I believe that, being social creatures, our relationships help us define who we are. Unfortunately, he realized it a bit too late.

A weird side note... without knowing it, I ended up staying at a B&B this past summer on Stampede Road just north of Denali... probably just 2-3 miles as the crow flies from the bus. The locals basically see Chris as "that boy who died in that bus out there." They run snowmobile trips to the bus in the winter.
This page was loaded Jul 4th 2009, 10:36 pm GMT.